A bulk process for making diamonds

 

"Lucky Lab Accident Yields New Recipe For Diamond Coating"

by Malcolm W. Browne, The New York Times, 3/12/96, pages B5 and B10

"By unintentionally substituting the wrong gas for one they intended to use for hardening tools, workers at a small metallurgical company have accidentally hit upon a potentially valuable method for coating objects with a hard diamond film.

"Specialists trying to learn why and how the method works warn that it has yet to prove its worth in industrial processing. But if the new diamond-coating technique proves to be as cheap, fast and effective as its inventors say, it may revolutionize the manufacture of machine tools, automobile engines, ships, beverage cans and much more, materials experts say.

"Although the discovery was made two years ago, it has not been reported in scientific journals, and information about it has spread mainly by word of mouth.

"The discoverer of the new method is Pravin Mistry, a 43-year-old British metallurgist who founded a small, privately owned engineering company, QQC Inc, in Dearborn, Michigan... Mr. Mistry's company specializes in applying coatings to industrial objects so as to impart desirable properties.

" 'This is an interesting instance of technology leading science,' said Dr. Rustum Roy, who heads the Diamond and Related Materials Center at Pennsylvania State University. 'There is no question that this fellow is coating all kinds of things with diamond, and doing it astonishingly rapidly and well, under conditions that no scientists imagined would work.'

"Part of Mr. Mistry's method involves four powerful and finely tuned laser beams, which interact as they scan the surface of an object as it is coated. As Mr. Mistry explains it, the scanning takes place in a gaseous environment, and the intense heat at the spot where the lasers converge breaks up some of the gas into an electrically charged plasma. The lasers also vaporize a very thin layer of the object being coated. ... By continuing to deposit atoms from the hot gas on the coated object, the thickness of the coating can be rapidly increased to up to a half inch, Mr. Mistry said.

"In 1994, Mr. Mistry's group made its discovery while using this interacting laser technique to apply a coating of hard titanium diboride to the surface of an aluminum object. An error in their procedure set the stage for a surprise that may prove to be immensely profitable for all concerned: someone accidentally substituted carbon dioxide for the nitrogen gas used in the process. A dense coating formed rapidly, but it did not consist of the intended titanium diboride. It turned out to be diamond.

"News of the discovery spread rapidly among materials experts, who were amazed that Mr. Mistry's technique for coating objects with diamond films was reportedly 1000 times faster than existing diamond-coating techniques. Moreover, the Mistry process promised to form particularly strong bonds between the coating and the metal objects to which it was applied, a vital requirement for hardened machine tools.

"The United States Navy, Army and Air Force, and the Defense Department's Advanced Research Projects Agency, as well as automotive companies, are following developments with interest.

" 'I have seen objects coated using Mr. Mistry's process, and I can verify that the coating is diamond,' said Dr. Robert Pohanka, director of materials research at the Office of Naval Research in Arlington, Virginia. 'I have visited the plant and seen the equipment.'

"Mr. Mistry said in interviews that the technique was in its infancy, but that all indications suggested that the coating was cheap and could be applied in closely controlled shapes and thicknesses, with excellent adhesion to objects.

"If the Mistry process lives up to expectations, Dr. Pohanka said, it could be used to apply hard coatings to gears and bearings, to cover pumps and other machinery with corrosion-resistant coatings... and to harden engine components to reduce wear.

"Dr. Roy, whose research group has undertaken an investigation of the scientific basis of the Mistry process, believes it could be used almost like a paint brush to apply coatings of diamond or other special materials. 'Mr. Mistry's equipment is operated by robots under computer control,' he said, 'and since the method is so flexible, it might some day be possible to coat an entire ship's hull with a film made of diamond or some other protective material.' "


Apparently Pravin Mistry and his colleagues are stuck on the idea of applying a coating of diamond to an existing object. It has not occurred to them that the substrate is just a substrate -- the diamond itself is the main thing. This technique could be used to make all kinds of things out of diamond.

Lasers don't have to be macroscopic (see, for example, Stephen R. Forrest, "Lasing from a molecular sieve," Nature, 28 January 1999, page 294, and Michael Brooks, "Heart of Chaos," New Scientist, 9 January 1999, page 28). Given microscopic lasers, the Mistry process could be used to make very fine-grained diamond structures.

However, the Mistry process is not molecular nanotechnology. The carbon atoms are not singled out and put in place individually, they are deposited from a gas (or plasma) onto a surface. This will still be true even if the lasers are miniaturized. The Mistry process is inherently a bulk process.

 
 

 



< rant > So far, the Mistry technique has been used to make... golf clubs. How depressing. I wonder what they will think of next. Maybe diamond speakers that will broadcast Muzak everywhere, so it's impossible to get away from it. Or how about diamond sensors the DEA can use to find every marijuana plant in the world...

New materials and processes will emerge into the same society we already live in. Diamond, like plastic, will just amplify the culture that's already there. To change the culture, more direct means are necessary. One thing that would help would be for people who do something they are proud of to stand up in public and say "I was stoned when I thought of this idea. In the real world, as opposed to the propaganda world we are supposed to live in, this is what pot actually does." For most people, the word "marijuana" is not grounded in experience. Ungrounded language can have unpredictable and sometimes devastating consequences. Ultimately the only way to fight the drug war is to challenge the unreality on which it is based. < end of rant >


back to "Positional Synthesis vs. Chemistry"